Part One

I've recently been in contact with Shawn Scott, Dorothy's son. He added some interesting things to my investigation of his mother's cold case. First off I was able to obtain a few pictures of Dorothy that he sent me. I wanted to see more than just the grainy newspaper pic we all have seen a thousand times. 






Also, Swinger's Psych Shop was a store that was previously owned by Dorothy's Father Jacob Scott. John Kycola purchased that store having already owned Custom John's Shop in Anaheim.




 Apparently there was a suspect that Shawn became aware of through several of Dorothy's friends who lived in Missouri. The suspects name was MIKE BUTLER. Apparently, Butler was an unstable individual who lived in the Santiago Mountains and was involved in cult activity. Which makes me think the dead dog that was discovered with her remains makes all the more sense now. Apparently he was obsessed with Dorothy. (Sound like our caller anyone?) His sister worked with Dorothy at Swinger's Psych Shop. (Funny, It makes total sense now as to how the stalker would know Dorothy's schedule so well.) Butler's sister has done pretty well for herself. She is somewhat of a local celebrity. She is a singer who still does concerts. I am NOT going to release her name at this time. Those who do research will figure it out. Shawn has tried on numerous occasions to speak with her and she avoids it from what I understand. Apparently LE was aware of Butler at the time. But never had enough evidence to consider him a suspect or person of interest. An interesting aspect of this is that when I was giving Shawn the breakdown of what I knew about his mother's case he was never told the names of Pam Head and Conrad Bostron. He knew of the story. But the names as far as he knows were never mentioned to him. I still stand by my suspicions regarding Head and Bostron's story. Something doesn't make sense. The part about them knowing Dorothy's parents phone number makes more sense now. Apparently after Dorothy's Father sold Swinger's to John Kocyla. John would still use Jacob as sort of a handy man to fix things around the shop. And his number was something well known to the employees of Swinger's. I do not remember reading that Jacob Scott owned Swinger's anywhere on the various online sites and newspaper articles I read about this case. But that part makes sense now. Another thing is that the employees of Swinger's were all like family to the Scotts. And Jacob Scott never suspected anyone at Swinger's to be involved. I tend to disagree here. The time frame in which it took Bostron and Head to call anyone regarding Dorothy "leaving" still does not make sense to me. Shawn and I also discussed his mother and if he remembers a lot about her. Unfortunately he does not. He was only 4. But from what he understands she was very loving and caring. He told me she made her own clothes out of old curtains to make sure she could buy him what he needed. And that after she was murdered. Dorothy's circle of friends offered to adopt Shawn. But his Grandfather Jacob Scott wouldn't have it. Apparently Jacob Scott had a major positive impact on Shawn. Apparently Jacob Scott passed away on Dorothy's Birthday in 1994. I suspect it was grief. 

UPDATE 5-5-18


I'm went ahead and added some info to this original update. I've sat on this for a good amount of time. I am gonna go ahead and say that im not sure how good a suspect Butler is regarding Dorothy's murder. But I was able to find some info on him. (I was emailed some of the info by a reader of this blog.) As you can see. He has passed away. 






Michael James Butler

BIRTH 06 MAR 1946  Pawtucket, Rhode Island, USA

DEATH 28 JUNE 2014  Olga, San Juan County, Washington, USA

Mike Butler: In Memoriam


— submitted from the family via Tom Tillman —
Mike Butler 3Have you ever noticed a person who seems interested in you, not for a particular reason or because they want something from you, but genuinely interested in you and who you are.
They want to help you simply because to them, it seems the right thing to do.  Perhaps they might to talk to you about a problem you might be struggling with, and guide you towards some possible options or resolutions. Or, maybe they might seem to sense you are just a little lonely, and might want to talk to another person who will listen and be sincerely concerned with what you have to say.
He might show up at your doorstep, wanting to fix your toilet leak, or that annoying noise your “whatchamacallit” is making,  often without even charging you anything for his  time or the supplies.
If you met Mike Butler, you undoubtedly recognize he was just that sort of person.
A bear of a man, Mike did not look the type you necessarily wanted as a neighbor – or even as a  friend. With a full “scraggly” beard and a seemingly endless number of hats that he and his friends could laugh about and even wear, Mike cut a path that others just felt inclined to follow, because they sensed his good, old fashioned desire to be wherever you might need him. He readily shared his zeal for his beliefs. He was a deeply religious man. Many islanders’ lives were touched by Mike.
Mike was born to loving parents; his mother, a New Zealand war bride, his father a dedicated career Army Captain. He was an Army brat as the young family followed the assigned Army posts.
When his father retired, the family settled in southern California.  Mike was well accustomed to being an athlete as well. Voted MVP for Cross Country Track, he graduated from Fullerton Union High School in the early 1960s, and went on to attend California State University, Fullerton, majoring in English.
He was drafted into the United States Army at the age of 20, finished Basic Training and Advanced Individual Training in Infantry,  and then something  very unusual happened: Mike’s attitude and attention to detail was noted and he was trained and served as a Drill Instructor for new recruits. After serving briefly in that capacity he was assigned overseas to Hohenfels, Germany in 1967 and became a News Writer/Reporter and was often published in Stars and Stripes News. He served as the Base Commanders Public Information and Media Officer and photographer as well.
When Mike’s time in the Army was complete, his civilian life was quite different from the military life he had been used to. He became a Music Roadie for several rock bands, including the Beach Boys and Birtha, an all girl rock band his sister was a member of. Soon he was settled in Orange County, California and was employed as a Machine Shop Maintenance employee, and later as an Electrician at Biola College.
He found his way to Orcas Island and felt he had found his lifetime home. He was the “Go-To” guy for home and business repair, a multi talented handyman, locksmith and Property Manager. He was the “go to guy” for Cherie Lindholm Real Estate for over two decades. He assisted as a Volunteer Medic for the community. He was also a talented recycled-artist, and his legacy can be seen today in the many unique signs on Orcas Island. On June 28, 2014, Mike succumbed to health issues that were terminal.
He is survived by five siblings: brother Chris Butler of Orcas Island, sisters Rosemary Butler of Sherman Oaks, Elizabeth Petersen of Whittier, Virginia Butler of Lake Forest and Barbara and Jim Bratton of Hesperia, California. He is interred at Olga Doe Bay Cemetery in Olga, Washington on Orcas Island.
But what Mike Butler was most known for was his ability to be a visionary, confidante, trusted neighbor and loyal friend. He will be deeply missed by many.






Orcas Icon Mike Butler Passes


— from Doug Marshall —
Mike Butler 3Mike Butler was buried this morning (Sunday, June 29, 2014), at Olga Cemetery.
Mike had been dealing with pancreatic cancer for some time.  At the point he needed more intensive care, he was welcomed into the home of his longtime friends Tonya and Blake Baida, who provided loving care and support.
Mike passed away early Saturday morning, and at his request he was quickly given a “green burial” with the help of many, many Orcas Island friends.  A simple but beautiful casket was built by Tom Meadows, using materials donated by Island Hardware. Others hand-dug his grave and selected personal items to be buried with him.
About 70 people were able to attend his funeral, in spite of the short notice.  In accordance with his strong Christian faith, the Lord’s Prayer was read in the King James version, honoring one of the many stickers on his iconic blue pickup:  “If it ain’t King James, it ain’t Bible!”
Mike was 68, and a U. S. Army veteran. He was employed for years by Cherie L. Lindholm Real Estate. He is survived by five siblings.
A “Celebration of Life” ceremony will be announced.


UPDATE: 7/23/2019

LA TIMES 1/18/2019

Continue reading




Not a lot about this case online. This post will likely be the most detailed on the case you will find.

UPDATE: WOULD LIKE TO THANK MEAGHAN FROM THE CHARLEY PROJECT FOR ADDING TERESA TO THE CHARLEY PROJECT. AS WELL AS FOR GIVING ME CREDIT IN HER SOURCES. THANKS MEAGHAN!


Additional Update-6/22/2019

I have attempted to contact members of Teresa's family. To no avail. Both her parents are now deceased. If any other member of her family is willing to discuss this case. Please email me. 




(Literally the only picture I can find!)

Teresa Lawyer Wisner

Case Number: I90E1013 (Madison County Sheriffs Department) 
Reported: 10/2/91
Last Seen: 5/24/1990 Walking along Indiana State Rd. 37. Around 10:30 pm. Prior to that she was last seen at Roxie's Airport Inn in Elwood, Indiana.
Maiden Name: Teresa Lynn Lawyer
Date Of Birth: 4/13/1966
Height: 5'1
Weight: 130 lbs
Hair: Reddish Blonde/Brown
Eyes: Blue
Clothing: Last seen wearing a White and Gray Sweatsuit. Gold Purse with Gold Trim. Gold Chain with a Diamond Pendant. 
Spouse: Married James L. Wisner on 10/12/85. By all accounts it was a rocky relationship. They did have a 2 year old son at the time she disappeared. She was in the process of seeking a divorce and had an appointment with an attorney the following morning. (Interesting huh?)
Son: At the time she had a 2 year old son named Jimmy. James L. Wisner being the father. 
Parents: Walter ("Sonny") and Wilma Lawyer



                                             Marriage Certificate

Excerpts from the Herald Bulletin 4/16/91

"Earlier in in the investigation, Two Elwood men reported seeing a woman matching Teresa Wisner's description about 10:30 pm on May 24th. She was walking along Indiana 37."

"They reported seeing a small gray car, Similar to the Toyota owned by the couple, Drive up alongside her. It appeared to be a man inside who exchanged words with her." (APD Detective Bob Blount stated)

"The man then shouted obscenities at the woman and drove away."

"Blount said the Elwood men later identified Wisner's Toyota as the car they had seen last May by the sound of the muffler."

Herald Bulletin 4/20/91


* Apparently Teresa voiced her dissatisfaction to her parents regarding her marriage prior to her disappearance.
* Wilma Lawyer said James Wisner talked to them about Teresa's behavior prior to May and asked her and Sonny to persuade Teresa to reconsider the decision to divorce him.

* Madison County Police Detective Bob Blount said he has talked with the Lawyers several times and suspects homicide after receiving a letter addressed to the couple. The letter reported Wisner's fear that she was in danger and named the source of her suspected danger.




OTHER FACTS

*According to Detective Bob Blount a "Foul Oder was reported at Wisner's home 2 days after wife disappeared." And a Search Warrant was obtained on 4/21/91. 
* Brother in Law later found car abandoned. A 1979 Toyota.(Uh-Huh Sure!) 
* Wilma and Sonny later went through the legal system to obtain visitation rights for Jimmy.

Bottom Left Conner: CrimeStoppers 







MY THOUGHTS


Not a lot to go on with this case since there is so little online to find. Tried reaching out to her son Jimmy as well as his wife via Facebook. Never received a response. I do have contact info for her parents who are still in the area. I might reach out to them at some point. I agree its obviously a homicide. I doubt the mom would willingly just leave and never contact the son. The report of her walking down State Road 37 is very telling if we can believe that it was her. I believe it was. James L. Wisner's brother found the car and a search warrant was issued from the Anderson Police Department for James L. Wisner's residence. Its clear where the investigators were going with the investigation. And Detective Bob Blount stated he suspected homicide. No body and no other evidence shows why this investigation is cold. 

Continue reading



NOTE: I would like to point out that I use the term "Suspect" in this entry a little freely. I do not believe that LE has labeled either Donthe Lucas or his mom Sara Lucas as suspects. However in my eyes they clearly are. Also I titled this entry The Murder of Kelsie Jean Schelling. When there is no evidence so far that a murder happened. But in my opinion one clearly did.


"We believe that she was killed,"
said Pueblo Police Captain Eric Bravo, the detective in charge of Kelsie Schelling's case

"We know he's the last person that was with her, last person to see her alive, the last person to talk to her,"
said Pueblo Police Capt. Eric Bravo. "I believe he did kill Kelsie."




helpfindkelsie@gmail.com 
Kelsie Jean Schelling

DOB: 2/18/1991 (21 Years Old at time of disappearance)
Height and Weight: 5'2-5'4 120lbs
Hair: Dark Brown
Eyes: Hazel
Race: Caucasian
Complexion: Tan
Tattoos: Chinese Symbol on Back Of Neck,
Cursive Writing on Inside of Left Arm. A Fleur-De-Lis on Right Rib Cage.
Clothing: A black coat with a fur-trimmed hood over a light gray jacket, black Victoria's Secret workout pants, tan UGG's boots and stud earrings. Carrying a black and pink Victoria's Secret bag containing personal belongings, including a day's worth of clothing and personal hygiene items.
Parents: Laura Saxton and Doug Schelling
Brother: Colby Schelling

* Last seen 2/5/13 in Pueblo, Colorado


* Had an ultra sound done the prior day confirming she was pregnant. The father being Donthe Lucas.

* She was 8 weeks pregnant at the time. Due date being September 13th.
* The baby's name was going to be Kadrie.

* Was last scene on Feb 4th, 2013 in the area of Manor Ridge Drive and Sienna Drive in Pueblo, Colorado.

****Kelsie took 3 Pregnancy Tests prior to going to Pueblo. Both Donthe and Kelsie both knew that she was pregnant. This is something that is not usually reported correctly.**** 



Breakdown of Case


TRUE CRIME DAILY
I DO NOT OWN THE RIGHTS TO THIS PROGRAM
I AM STRICTLY USING THIS VIDEO FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES

It scares me to death that it could go on for the rest of my life. I mean that’s a possibility I don’t want to face,”


said Laura Saxton,
Kelsie Schelling’s mother



Donthe "HOOPDREAMS" Lucas


*Kelsie Schelling met Donthe Isiah Lucas at Northeastern Junior College in 2010
*Donthe was a standout basketball player from Central High School in Pueblo. He was a forward for the Plainsmen.
*After two years at Northeastern, Schelling went to Vanguard University, a Christian school in Costa Mesa, Calif., and Lucas went to Emporia State University in Kansas, hoping to play ball for the Division 1 school.
*Schelling moved into an apartment in Denver at the end of the first semester at Vanguard University and got a job at Floor & Decor, a Highlands Ranch store.
* Lucas went to visit her over Christmas break, and this was when she became pregnant. Schelling told her mother Lucas wasn't happy about the pregnancy; sometimes she was afraid he would abandon her and the baby after it was born, and other times he threatened to take the baby away from her.

*On Sunday, Feb. 3, 2013, Donthe sent a series of e-mails to Kelsie trying to persuade her to drive the two hours to his home in Pueblo after she worked at Floor & Decor. It was apparent by the texting exchange that she had an appointment with a doctor the next morning and Donthe knew about it.
*The Denver Post notes he was aware of the pregnancy long before she sent him the photo.
*Schelling, 22, drove from Denver to Pueblo on the night of Feb. 4, 2013, to meet her boyfriend, Donthe Lucas.
*Police say cell phone records indicate she made it to Pueblo, but hasn't been seen since.
*The car was eventually found more than a week later, on Feb. 14, at St. Mary-Corwin Hospital, four miles east of the Walmart where it had last been seen.
*Video surveillance from a Walmart parking lot in Pueblo shows Schelling’s black 2011 Chevrolet Cruze parked in front of the store around 12:05 pm on Feb 5th. The vehicle was left there overnight. The next morning at 7:20 a.m., an unidentified man can be seen getting into Schelling’s car and driving away.

*Pueblo detectives interviewed Lucas on Feb. 15, 2013. He denied knowing what had happened to his girlfriend.
*Schelling's bank account has been accessed and messages had been sent from her cell phone in the days after she disappeared.
*Donthe Lucas was arrested for identity theft for using Schelling's credit card. He was not charged with murder. Lucas was held on three counts of identity theft and theft of less than $500, according to Pueblo County District Court records. But the charges were later dropped. He was released on a $25,000 surety bond.
*During an initial interview with police, Lucas told detectives he went with Schelling to Parkview Medical Center in Pueblo because she wasn't feeling well. Lucas said she went in for two hours and then came out and told him she wasn't pregnant anymore. However the medical center had no record of Schelling ever stepping foot in the building. Additionally, surveillance video from a bank showed Lucas driving up alone in Schelling's car and withdrawing $400 in cash from her bank account.

*Mr Lucas proceeded to drive the vehicle to a bank, where he withdrew $400 using Ms Schelling’s ATM card. (Canon National Bank)
*Investigators have reported that there has been no other activity from Schelling on her financial accounts, her cell phone or on social media.
*In early April of 2013, K-9 dogs were used in a search for Kelsie.
*In September 2013, Pueblo police released information confirming the worst possible outcome. “The Pueblo Police Department believes that these facts make it a probability that Kelsie has met with foul play due to her disappearance,” [Police Press Release]
*On Feb. 3, the Pueblo Police Department released another statement on Kelsie’s case.
Schelling is still missing, and her family needs closure. We believe there is someone out there who has intimate knowledge of the incident, but may feel reluctant to come forth with the information. Please know that your information may be that one missing piece we are needing to bring this case to a conclusion,” the news release says.
* Schelling left all her belongings behind at her apartment and gave no indication that she planned to walk out of her life.
LUCAS AKA HOOPDREAMS

 Pictured here: HOOPDREAMS trying to be GANGSTA

Suspect- 
Donthe Isiah Richard "HOOPDREAMS" Lucas (born 1992) 
Donthe's Story:

Lucas was interviewed by police on February 15. He said he met Schelling as planned and drove her in her car to different locations. He said she felt sick, so he took her to Parkview Medical Center in the 400 block of west 16th Street, and stayed in the car while she went inside to get medical attention. Afterwards they went to the 
Canon National Bank, where Schelling allowed him to use her debit card and withdraw money from her account. He then took her to Wal-Mart, where they got into an argument and she told him she had to go back to Denver because she had to work the next day.

(There is no record of Schelling getting treatment at Parkview Medical Center, and surveillance video at the hospital didn't show her coming inside.)



Age: 24
Old MySpace:
(HoopStar23! Lmfao!)
YOU GOT TO BE KIDDING ME!!!!!
Yeah we sure do!!!!!

Mother: Sara Jennene "HoopDreamer" Lucas 48, (Also a Suspect and likely an Accomplice)


Timeline

2/3/13- Donthe Lucas sends texts to Kelsie requesting her to come to Pueblo to meet him. That he has something to give her. But wont elaborate on what it is.
Text Exchange:
Dumbass: Just wait and see for yourself, You probably wont believe me if I told you.
Kelsie: Tell me what it is and Ill come.
Dumbass: Come see for yourself I know it will put you in a better mood.
2/4/13- Kelsie attends her prenatal appointment and ultrasound confirms that baby Kadrie is healthy. She sends pics of the ultrasound to her family as well as Donthe's.
She drives to Pueblo after working her shift at Home & Décor and arrives shortly after 11pm.
2/5/13- (Early morning hours. A little after midnight.) She texts Donthe a text telling him she was tired of waiting. Donthe responds and wants to arrange a new meeting place. Kelsie agrees and arrives near his grandmothers house at 5113 Manor Ridge Dr. Kelsie sends him a text.
"Where are you? I've been waiting here over an hour just waiting."(Text was sent at 12:15am)
Shortly after Noon on the 5th. CCTV Footage shows Donthe Lucas parking Schelling's car at the Walmart she drove to meet him in the early morning hours. CCTV shows Donthe Lucas stepping out of the passenger side door and walking away. (12:05pm)
2/6/13- An unidentified man is seen getting into Schelling's car and driving away. (By the same CCTV Camera)
2/7/13- The same unidentified man is seen dropping the car off at St. Mary Crown Point Hospital in Pueblo by Surveillance Cameras. According to LE Kelsie's Cell Phone Battery dies.
2/11/13- Kelsie's Family set up a Facebook Page
2/14/13- Kelsie's car is found abandoned in St. Mary Corwin Hospital.
2/15/13- Donthe Lucas is arrested for 3 Counts of Identity Theft and Theft of Less Than $500. Charges were later dropped.




   (The light colored car is Sara Lucas's car)




Other Interesting Facts:
Things that are missing from Kelsie's car:
  • Tie Died Teddy Bear
  • A Black Rosary
  • Metal Love Sign
  • Set of keys for her Chevy Cruze car. Has a Love Keychain attached.
  • Purse
  • Wallet
  • Pair of UGGs
  • Army Backpack
(These things were likely stolen to make it seem like her car was dumped and possessions stolen)

On 05/1/2015 signs were put in place at the Walmart in Pueblo for Kelsie. On 05/4/2015 all were removed by an unknown person.


Suspect stealing the signs
Suspect Vehicle

APRIL 17TH UPDATE:
 5113 Manor Ridge Dr.

Police searched a field approximately one mile from Lucas's old residence. During excavation, police said they'd uncovered items of possible evidentiary value. At this point, they're not saying if something they found inspired a search of the field.



Links:

CBS Denver Links:

MY THOUGHTS


 THIS IS SO SIMPLE. HOOPDREAMS ASKS HER TO COME TO PUEBLO. HOOPDREAMS IS SEEN AT HER CAR. HOOPDREAMS ISNT CONCERNED ENOUGH TO LOOK FOR HER. HOOPDREAMS STEALS MONEY FROM HER WITH KELSIE'S ATM CARD. HOOPDREAMS REFUSES TO TAKE A POLYGRAPH TEST. HOOPDREAMS....YOU'RE A PIECE OF SHIT. AND YOU'RE GOING TO PRISON. AND YOUR MOM IS LIKELY GOING TO AS WELL. ALSO, I WOULDNT DISCOUNT A HITMAN TYPE SCENARIO. WITH BOTH SARA AND DONTHE BEING COMPLICIT WITH IT. IT WOULD EXPLAIN THE MISSING ITEMS IN THE CAR. (KINDA) AS WELL AS THE MYSTERY MAN TAKING DOWN THE SIGNS AND DRIVING THE CAR TO THE HOSPITAL. YES, I THINK THE GUY THAT TOOK THE CAR TO THE HOSPITAL AND THE ONE THAT REMOVED THE SIGNS ARE THE SAME PERSON.







Continue reading




Thanks for visiting! Come back often!